Short answer: A pilot that keeps going out is most often a worn thermocouple, a dirty pilot, or a draft or venting problem. A pilot that goes out is the safety system doing its job, but if you smell gas at any point, you leave first and call from outside.
- Smell gas? Do not relight anything. Go outside, then call your gas or propane company or 911.
- No gas smell: relighting once, using the instructions printed on your tank, is a normal first step.
- It lights, then dies when you let go of the knob: a worn thermocouple is the common cause.
- It keeps going out: stop relighting and call or text Ryan.
Gas Safety Comes First
If you smell gas, do not touch the heater. Leave the house with everyone in it, do not flip a light switch or use anything that could spark, and call your gas or propane company or 911 once you are outside. Propane suppliers and gas utilities all give the same steps. The full list is on the page smell gas in the house.
Once the house has been cleared and the gas company says it is safe, a leak in the water heater line is a repair for a licensed plumber. Ryan does gas leak detection and gas line work. Do not turn gas back on if it was shut off because of a safety problem.
If you do not smell gas, a pilot that went out is common and usually not an emergency. The rest of this page is for that case.
Why a Pilot Light Keeps Going Out
A standing pilot is a small flame that stays lit to light the main burner. A safety device watches it. If the pilot goes out, the device shuts off the gas so raw gas does not build up. That is on purpose. When the pilot keeps going out, one of a few parts or conditions is usually behind it.
- A worn thermocouple. The thermocouple is a small metal probe that sits in the pilot flame. It makes a tiny electric signal that tells the gas valve a flame is present. When the probe gets dirty or weak, the valve decides the flame is gone and closes. The classic sign is a pilot that lights while you hold the knob and dies a few seconds after you let go.
- A dirty pilot. Dust, lint or soot can clog the small pilot opening. The flame gets weak or yellow and is easy to blow out.
- A draft or a venting problem. A downdraft, a blocked flue, or a tight room with not enough air can blow the pilot out or starve it. Wind through a basement door, a crawlspace vent or a loose flue pipe can do the same.
- A failing gas control valve. If the thermocouple tests fine and the pilot still will not hold, the gas valve itself may be failing.
- Gas supply trouble. An empty propane tank or a closed shut-off can look exactly like a bad heater.
Pilot out and you are not sure why?
Text Ryan a photo of the heater and the label on the tank, and tell him what happens when you relight it. He is a licensed Master Plumber and answers his own phone, day or night.
Relighting Safely, Once
Every gas water heater has relighting steps printed on a label on the tank. Use those, not a video for a different model. The manufacturer's steps change from model to model, and they include waiting time for any leftover gas to clear. Here is the general approach.
- Make sure you do not smell gas. If you do, stop and go outside.
- Read the label on your tank and follow it exactly, including any wait time.
- Try once. If it lights and stays lit, watch it for a few minutes and check a hot tap later.
- If it will not stay lit, stop. Do not keep trying again and again. Repeated relights do not fix a worn part.
Newer heaters often have no standing pilot. They use an electronic igniter and may show a blinking light that signals a problem. The label usually explains the pattern. If you cannot tell which kind you have, a photo to Ryan is a quick way to find out.
Propane, Cabins and Basements
A lot of homes and cabins in the mountains run on propane. Check the gauge on the tank before you assume the heater is bad. A tank that ran empty is one of the simplest reasons for a pilot that will not light. If the tank has been refilled, a plumber may need to purge air from the line before the heater lights.
Water heaters in basements and crawlspaces also catch drafts and dust. A crawlspace vent left open in winter, a window near the unit or a new fan in the room can pull air across the pilot. If the pilot goes out when the furnace or a fan kicks on, mention that when you text. It helps Ryan find the cause faster. If the heater is also making noise, see water heater making noise.
What Not to Do
- Do not hold the knob down for a long time or defeat the safety device. That device is what keeps gas from flowing with no flame.
- Do not use a lighter or match near the heater if you smell gas.
- Do not open a sealed combustion chamber.
- Do not wrap, block or cover the flue or the air openings.
- Do not relight a pilot after a gas shut-off for a safety concern. Call the gas company or a plumber first.
Carbon monoxide is the other gas risk with fuel-burning appliances. It has no smell. A blocked vent can send it into the house, which is one more reason a pilot that keeps failing deserves a proper look. The carbon monoxide and gas appliances guide explains the warning signs.
What a Repair Looks Like
Ryan checks the thermocouple, the pilot, the flue and the gas control, and tells you what he finds. A worn part is often a straightforward repair. If the tank is old or leaking, he will tell you that too. Water heater repair and replacement jobs typically run about $500 to $2,000 depending on the unit and the job, and the estimate is free before any work. There is no trip fee and no diagnostic fee. If the pilot is only one of several problems, the page on no hot water at all covers the rest of the gas and electric path.